12th Jan 2023, 4:03 pm | #41 |
Hexode
Join Date: Jun 2018
Location: Buckinghamshire, UK.
Posts: 387
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
|
12th Jan 2023, 4:33 pm | #42 |
Rest in Peace
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London, UK.
Posts: 2,508
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Correct. That is called the 'Carter system' in which the two 2-way switches switch the two sides of the lamp between Line and Neutral. It works, but there are a number of objections of which the key one is that the lamp is fully live in one of the off permutations.
The second trick employed here is earthed-concentric wiring, where the metallic sheath of the wiring system provides a combined-neutral-earth (CNE) a.k.a protective-earthed-neutral (PEN) conductor at every point. (Note - this is a conductor but it doesn't count as a 'core' which is what I kept referring to above). Earthed-concentric installations were permitted in the UK with certain wiring systems, such as mineral-insulated metallic-sheathed and proprietary metallic sheathed types such as Stannos. Specific precautions had to be taken with regard to ensuring continuity, as an interrupted or high-resistance PEN can result in all exposed wiring, fittings and loads becoming live through the load resistance. I.e. a broken PEN is much more serious than a broken protective earth. Earthed-concentric is one implementation, arguably the best, of TN-C configuration where the PEN extends all the way to the load. TN-C was permitted in many other countries and has been used as recently as 2001 in Finland. Under some regulations a PEN can be identified by colour, e.g. green/yellow with a blue band. In German wiring, a blue will be a neutral, a green/yellow an earth, but a grey could be either a simple neutral or a PEN. These days TN-C is only normally used in DNO's works up to the service terminal equipment, where the neutral and protective earth split as they enter the consumer's installation. Hence, TN-C-S (earthed neutral, part combined, part separate). Obviously full TN-C is not compatible with residual current protection. I have a sample of Stannos EC wiring connecting up some light switches and a socket. The cable sheaths are sweated into brass plugs that screw into the conduit spouts of fittings. It was a requirement that only threaded spouts be used to maintain PEN continuity, not bushes and couplers used on plain holes in CI or steel boxes. |
12th Jan 2023, 6:41 pm | #43 | |
Nonode
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Stafford, Staffs. UK.
Posts: 2,532
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
I don't know whether that ever got updated when they had a new CU installed. |
|
16th Jan 2023, 4:42 pm | #44 |
Heptode
Join Date: Oct 2019
Location: Täby, Sweden
Posts: 708
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
When I first moved into my house in Sweden it had not been rewired since the 60's. The colours in the fittings were White (L), Red (E) and Black (N). Thanks goodness for standards and harmonisation! And many houses still only have two wire (L + N) for sockets since the buildings are wood and retrofitting is not mandatory.
|
16th Jan 2023, 10:45 pm | #45 |
Rest in Peace
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London, UK.
Posts: 2,508
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Wiring colours for electrical installations are interesting in the way that different standards evolved without de-facto standardisation of the meanings through association with familiar concepts. In the UK for example, we associated red with danger and made that the standard colour for line (or live, as it was then) and L1 of 3-phase. But as 'obvious' as it might sound in retrospect, it clearly isn't obvious by default. Because while we were using it as L1, it was L2 in Switzerland, L3 in Russia, neutral in Holland and Earth in Germany (amongst others). The fact that it has been chosen for all five conductors of a 3-phase TN-S system, suggests that it doesn't actually convey any meaning by itself. It didn't make it through the selection process for harmonisation, for obvious (or not so obvious) reasons.
Referring back to the title of the thread, I do enjoy learning about different standards and methods used around the world, which has been important in the day job. After 30 years of working on and designing electrics to various countries' standards I've become somewhat cosmopolitan and comfortable with a range of different approaches to the same end result. It's remarkable how parochial electrical knowledge tends to be, because the trade's teaching syllabus is often based directly on the local regulations. Talk to a British spark and the chances are they won't know the American term for a 2-way light switch circuit, let alone the name of the cable used to wire it, its current rating, requirements for protection etc. Mention edge-grounded high-leg open delta and you might as well be speaking Martian. In a way, that makes it pointless to harmonise wiring colours because if you come from a background of different installation practice, you won't know which kind of wire to use or how you are allowed to install it. Once you've mastered all of that detail for the local standards, learning half a dozen colours is trivial. |
17th Jan 2023, 12:28 am | #46 |
Heptode
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Warminster, Wiltshire, UK.
Posts: 682
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Just a few things I thought I would mention. In the old days I’m talking about 60s 70s that I thought might be of interest.
It was quite common if we had a lighting circuit with no Earth and we required a earth for a metal light fittings we would run a single each wire from a socket to provide one .not the best practice but we would never dream of re wiring a lighting circuit with no earth. Also in the old days it was considered bad practice to loop in at the switches and you would almost never have a neutral at a switch . One other thing that was bad practice was on 2 way switches if you had a twin cable going to the switch. Ie a live and switched live returning to the light fitting. We were never allowed to connect it across the straps on the triple cable going between the the two switches. The live was put in a connector together with the red of the triple going to the next switch .With the straps yellow and blue having no connection apart from between each switch . The common of the first switch had the switch return feeding back to the light . In later years we stopped putting the connector on the common and put the live and live return across the straps. How things have changed. One point worth remembering . In the old days on 2 way switching 60% of electricians used the red for common and 40% used yellow. Approximately. Or at least in my area. Even to this day including myself a large amount of electricians use brown for common .The others use black for common. No disrespect to anyone but I refuse to call a Earth wire a CPC and Live Line . Andy
__________________
I bet that car doesn't have a suppressor. |
17th Jan 2023, 11:03 am | #47 |
Dekatron
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Oxford, UK.
Posts: 17,863
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Our new (2011) house has neutrals in each light switch, something I'd not encountered before and didn't realise was "a thing". A nice touch for the reasons Lucien mentions in post 36, but the actual implementation is messy: each switch is mounted on a 25mm-deep backbox which invariably has choc block connectors squished into its depths, but so that there's enough room for the guts of the dimmer switches, the front edge of the backbox is sunk about 3/4" below the face of the plaster. There are also a hell of a lot of wires in quite a small space!
This photo was taken after I'd hacked out all the plaster that had run into the box! Last edited by Nickthedentist; 17th Jan 2023 at 11:11 am. |
17th Jan 2023, 12:11 pm | #48 |
Heptode
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Warminster, Wiltshire, UK.
Posts: 682
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Nick
That’s probably the normal these days . If it was me I would use smaller earth sleeving. Also in your picture any lives if not brown should have brown sleeving on them also any neutrals not blue should have blue sleeving on them . So we don’t go off topic . If you compare that to the old days there would be no looping in of wires on a domestic property at the switch If we couldn’t get all the wires in a ceiling rose then we would use joint boxes under floors. Infact some electricians would use joint boxes anyway so as to only have a twin cable and possibly a earth at the light fitting . We would sometimes have a large joint box under a landing floor and several rooms would have the centre light and switch wires terminate there . In the old days wall lights were common and they would be fed from a similar joint box . Almost never looped between fittings . Andy
__________________
I bet that car doesn't have a suppressor. |
17th Jan 2023, 12:23 pm | #49 | ||
Dekatron
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Oxford, UK.
Posts: 17,863
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
Agreed about the narrower earth sleeving. But it can be surprisingly hard to get hold of. I ordered a 100m hank of it from CPC a few years ago and they sent me the wide stuff which would confortably accept several conductors from 2.5mm T+E. When I queried it, they said the narrow gauge was NLA because it was no longer manufactured, but they hadn't updated their catalogue or website. Having said that, I spotted some in one of the DIY sheds last year, and grabbed it. Quote:
|
||
17th Jan 2023, 2:35 pm | #50 |
Nonode
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Stafford, Staffs. UK.
Posts: 2,532
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Our previous house, built 1993 had Neutral behind the switches. First time I'd seen it.
This house built 1999 doesn't have that. I wish it did as I'd be able to use one of an array of 'smart' switches or relays that need N to get power. As it is the lack of Neutral at the switch means the smart dimmer needs to 'steal' power from bewteen its input and output. |
17th Jan 2023, 4:37 pm | #51 | |
Heptode
Join Date: Feb 2022
Location: Leicestershire, UK.
Posts: 690
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
Rog |
|
17th Jan 2023, 5:01 pm | #52 |
Dekatron
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Oxford, UK.
Posts: 17,863
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
I had some of those, branded Smiths Timeguard, about 25 years ago. They worked very well for switching on domestic lights automatically at dusk for a preset period, though of course the long "on" periods meant that the lamps wore out quickly and a lot of electricity was used. They were a simple 2-wire connection, replacing a standard lightswitch.
Still got them in the garage if anyone wants to play with one... |
17th Jan 2023, 5:13 pm | #53 | |
Dekatron
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Wiltshire, UK.
Posts: 14,007
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
__________________
I'm the Operator of my Pocket Calculator. -Kraftwerk. |
|
18th Jan 2023, 6:22 pm | #54 | |
Nonode
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Stafford, Staffs. UK.
Posts: 2,532
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
|
|
18th Jan 2023, 6:44 pm | #55 | ||
Heptode
Join Date: Feb 2022
Location: Leicestershire, UK.
Posts: 690
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
Rog |
||
18th Jan 2023, 7:35 pm | #56 | |
Heptode
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Cedar Grove, Wisconsin, USA.
Posts: 823
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
Dave, USradcoll1 |
|
18th Jan 2023, 8:05 pm | #57 | |
Nonode
Join Date: Jan 2016
Location: Stafford, Staffs. UK.
Posts: 2,532
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Quote:
Maybe it's a combination? Load resistor across the contacts to draw current through a series resistor when the contacts are open, relying on the load itself to draw current when the contacts are closed? All sounds a bit risky though and I'd hate to do calculations based on guessed loads. In the case of the devices I'm referencing, they use a semiconductor to switch. I'd guess a triac though I've never opened one to check. When off, you have full mains voltage between L and switched L. When on, if you don't switch on for 100% of the cycle then you have full mains voltage across the L and SL for the short period you switch off. Sneaky but it works. On the other hand it does mean you can never, quite, get 100% brightness, and you MUST use dimmable LEDs. I don't know what the actual duty cycle on '100% brightness' is and what real effect it has on the lamps output. |
|
18th Jan 2023, 9:11 pm | #58 |
Heptode
Join Date: Feb 2022
Location: Leicestershire, UK.
Posts: 690
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Hi Duncan,
Forgot to mention that the Timeguard unit actually replaces the light switch. So I would assume that when Timeguard OFF, the internal resistor in the is in series with the filament of the bulb [load] so in essence we have a potential divider circuit with the volt drop across the Timeguard resistor powering the electronics. As you say when the Timeguard switches to ON this is via a Triac so there will be enough residual non duty power via the internal resistor to keep the control electronics happy. Only a theory ? Rog |
19th Jan 2023, 3:21 am | #59 | |
Rest in Peace
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London, UK.
Posts: 2,508
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Duncan and Roger's analysis of parasitic power for dimmers & smart switches without a neutral is pretty much it. A capacitive and resistive dropper combo is typical. Many dimmers now use IGBTs insead of triacs, to enable trailing-ege control, which is more compatible with LED loads, plus more flexible power leeching at high overall conduction angles. For low power lighting loads it is often necessary to shunt the load with an RC network - a 0.1μF + 120Ω snubber network is popular - to ensure there is sufficient juice available for the dimmer. Others won't work at all with LEDs; compatibility is unpredictable and pretty much any new permutation of dimmer model and light model has to be verified before installation.
Quote:
Although not perfect, because a medium-depth box has been recessed too far leaving the masonry exposed, Nick's box actually has enough room for UK-style accessories with that number of cables, if properly arranged and dressed into place. Slightly more wire length would be preferable, so that they enter at the top, pass down the back of the box, turn forward at the bottom and come up to the correct terminal positions on the switch or dimmer. That way, once uncrewed, the switch will 'swing' down easily with minimal strain on the wires. It also allows spare in case any get damaged or need altering later. It should never be necessary to 'scrunch' them in behind the switch, unless they have been left too short. A factor that makes UK switches and outlets more forgiving of wire fill is the lack of risk of shorts. There are no side-wire screw terminals on our components, all screws and wire entries are recessed into the insulating body. You could rub your fingers all over the back and internal parts without touching live metal, just as you can with modern US / NEMA-format dimmers and smart switches with captive pigtail wiring. Plus, we fit PVC sleeving over all bare grounds, so there is no chance of a stray bare copper wire touching anything live. All these differences fascinate me. When I was designing and specifiying materials for electrical installations aboard EU-built but US-based cruise ships, that had to meet UK, EU, US and Lloyds regulations all at the same time (erm, what colour is a hot wire, people?) I had reps from Hubbell, Bryant etc. leaving me stuff for evaluation . I ended up with a big stash of NEMA-style accessories, mostly Hubbell's best, on and under my desk. I loved playing with stuff like that, some of the NEMA outlets for example put ours to shame, very nicely made and durable. Swings and roundabouts, no system has all the best bits. Last edited by Lucien Nunes; 19th Jan 2023 at 3:37 am. |
|
19th Jan 2023, 9:29 pm | #60 |
Rest in Peace
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London, UK.
Posts: 2,508
|
Re: Every day is a schoolday. House lighting circuits from the past.
Deleted post requires re-writing.
Last edited by Lucien Nunes; 19th Jan 2023 at 9:40 pm. Reason: Errors! |