I respect your knowledge/expertise much too much to argue with you; the crystals are not there but have been replaced by ceramic filters and anecdotal accounts (of the QST
original configuration) say these give "useful" performance.
This is backed up by Peter's account (on this forum and in his BVWS article) of his trial of the ceramics in an HRO. On that basis, the question is whether my proposed circuit has any obvious flaws, other than "lacking the quartz"?
Now, if I change the IF to 8.1MHz, my junk box certainly has a number of FT243 quartz crystals
.
B